How Sellers Should Interview a Realtor: Questions and Red Flags
Updated Nov 14, 2026 | By Scott Smolen, The Scott Smolen Team at RE/MAX Leading Edge in Crofton, MD, helping buyers and sellers since 1999.

When sellers interview a listing agent, I want them to leave with things they can actually evaluate: a marketing plan in writing, a suggested list price they can see the market data behind, that analysis left with them to review at their own pace, a clear picture of who handles the listing day-to-day and how they will be contacted, and a listing agreement that spells out what they will pay, what is included, and what happens if they cancel. I have been helping local buyers and sellers since 1999, and those are the points I tell sellers to press on before they sign.
For a broader checklist, including neighborhood experience, references and property type, see 10 Steps to Choosing the Right Realtor. This page is about the questions I hear sellers skip, and the red flags I would be very cautious of.
The first question I tell sellers to ask
The first question that every seller should ask an agent is what is their marketing plan, and how do they go about making sure that the home is going to get the maximum amount of exposure in today's market? If the agent does not have a scheduled marketing plan with a clear layout of what you can expect from him or her, that is a red flag. You do not want to be with an agent who is out there learning and throwing mud against the wall with your property. You want somebody who at least has a plan in place that has been proven for success, so you give yourself the best chance for success.
You should also ask, what similar homes have you sold, and what did you learn from them? Then let the agent explain if they have sold similar homes and how that went.
How to tell a list price is backed by evidence
A seller can tell a list price is backed by evidence based on the market analysis that any agent performs. It is not uncommon for agents to have different opinions of the market, and that is something you will come across on the other side from a buyer agent who might have a different opinion. What you have to look at is whether the price you are being given can be realistic based on the market data they are presenting. If an agent comes in and they don't share market data with you, or they are just telling you what you want to hear, that is a major problem. You should be able to look at it and see exactly what the basis is for the suggested list price.
Ask what price range the evidence supports, and why they would believe that. That should be clarified in their market analysis, in writing. Our market analysis is always left for the owner to keep in writing, so they can review it casually at their own time, with no pressure. If an agent wants to show you things and then take off with them without letting you keep it, that is a red flag.
A suggested list price is also not cut in stone. There should be some variable there depending on motivation. If somebody has a little more time, you might want to go a little bit higher. If somebody has to sell really quick because of an immediate job transfer, they might need to take that into consideration when they price their home. The most important factor is that, in order to get the highest price ultimately, you have to have your home exposed to as many potential buyers and as many potential spots as possible.
Start with a walk-through of the house as it sits
Ask what you should do before listing, and what they would skip. The first thing that any realtor should do when they come to your house to list it is take a walk around your property with you and have you show them the house in the condition as it sits. That is the first step, before you get to any other part of the conversation or the presentation. Any quality realtor has to know what they are being asked to sell in order to do an effective job marketing it and getting it sold.
What a marketing plan should include, and how you can check it

A marketing plan should be in writing, with a layout of what timing needs to be expected in order to execute all of these items. What we do with our clients is we make sure that the sellers are actually given proof that those items are done. We want to show them the links that we have and the marketing program that we have put together, because we welcome feedback. If there is something that we have published, we want to make sure it is accurate. Nobody knows a home better than the person living in it. So if we have something online, we want to make sure it is checked by the sellers and it meets their expectations, and that it is accurate so future buyers are not misled in any way.
Who handles the listing day-to-day
Another great question is, who handles my listing day-to-day, and what will you deliver? You need to make sure that you are not getting signed up with an agent who then disappears and turns you over to what they call a transaction coordinator. A lot of times the transaction coordinators are people who are not familiar with the property, are not in the area, have never been there, and don't know the details, and they end up getting the file dropped in their lap. There is nothing wrong with them handling paperwork or things of that nature, but if there is a question about your actual house, you want to make sure you are dealing with the person who has actually been there and seen it.
Set your communication expectations up front
Sellers need to make it clear up front what their expectations are for communications. Some sellers want to be talked to on a regular basis, and there is nothing wrong with that. Some prefer to be texted, some prefer email, and others prefer not to be contacted unless there is something that is either really good or really bad. Any way that you want it as a seller, it is your house, and you are selling it. You should communicate that with the agent and make sure that the agent's expectations can be met.
One thing I would be very cautious of, as a red flag, is if any agent comes in and says they are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. That is not true. Agents are human beings. They sleep. They have other things going on. They might have multiple appointments, or a doctor's appointment. Nobody is available 24/7 at a moment's notice. The question is, if I contact you, can I expect a callback, and how long will it take, or a response via email on a regular basis?
What we offer, since I have a team and Stacy is also there, is coverage when I cannot get to an email right away. If I am on a flight to an appointment or a conference for a couple of hours and an email comes in, Stacy can often reply and take care of anything that is necessary even before I land. Or even if she can't, she can at least say we have it, we are working on it, and we can take care of it. Any agent that promises 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, immediate response, that is a red flag.
Read the listing agreement before you sign
All the points in the listing agreement are valid. All of them should be read and understood.
You also want to ask what you will pay, what is included, and what happens if you cancel. That should all be spelled out clearly in the written listing agreement. If it is not, ask for it to be added in. If the agent pushes back on that, make sure you understand why, and that you are comfortable with it.
Some agents will ask for fees if somebody wants to cancel a contract early. That is up to the individual seller if they want to take on that type of risk. A lot of more experienced agents understand that we are in a business where we take risk when we take a house we are being asked to sell, and we spend money advertising it. If it is not a good fit and we don't think we can sell it, higher-level agents tend to turn down the listing, as opposed to just taking it and hoping for the best.
A red flag would be any kind of an extended length or an extended cancellation provision. If an agent wants a one-year listing, that is a red flag. A listing can always be extended. If you are happy, you can extend it without any problem at all. But if the agent is trying to lock you down into a long period of time, or saying you cannot get out of it without 90 days' notice, those are red flags. You want to work with somebody who wants to work with you. Our listing agreements are for very reasonable amounts of time, and either party can cancel with written notice, with a reasonable written notice.
You also want to work with an agent who has some basic understanding and common sense. For instance, I recently had a property that we had listed, and we did a listing agreement. We had it as coming soon, and the seller had a major medical issue and decided they could not sell their house. That was very understandable. Even though we had put some time and effort into it, we just said no problem. We mutually agreed to cancel the listing. The seller did not have to pay any money or pay any penalties, and when they are ready to sell, we will sell it for them then. You want to work with an agent who is reasonable, and somebody who you understand is not trying to lock you down by a piece of paper.
FAQ
What is the first question a seller should ask a listing agent? What is their marketing plan, and how will they make sure the home gets the maximum amount of exposure? If they do not have a scheduled plan with a clear layout of what you can expect, that is a red flag. Also ask what similar homes they have sold, and what they learned from them.
How can I tell if a suggested list price is backed by evidence? The agent should share the market analysis in writing, including what price range the evidence supports and why. If they do not share market data, or they are just telling you what you want to hear, that is a major problem. Our market analysis is always left for the owner to review at their own pace, with no pressure. If an agent shows it and then takes it away, that is a red flag. The list price is also not cut in stone and can vary with your timeline.
What should I expect to see in a marketing plan? It should be in writing, with a layout of the timing. You should also get proof that the work was done, including the links, so you can check it for accuracy. Nobody knows a home better than the person living in it.
What should happen first when an agent comes to list my house? The first step should be a walk-through of the house as it sits, before any other part of the conversation or the presentation. Ask what to do before listing, and what to skip. A quality realtor has to know what they are being asked to sell.
Who should handle my listing day-to-day? Ask who handles the listing day-to-day and what they will deliver. Watch for an agent who signs you up and then turns you over to a transaction coordinator who has never seen the house. Paperwork is fine for a coordinator, but questions about the house should go to the person who has actually been there.
Is it a good sign if an agent promises to be available 24/7? No. That is a red flag. Nobody is available 24/7 at a moment's notice. Ask whether you can expect a callback, and how long it will take, or a regular email response. On our team, if I am on a flight, Stacy can often reply before I land, or at least let you know we have it and we are working on it.
What should I watch for in the listing agreement before I sign? Read and understand all of it. Ask what you will pay, what is included, and what happens if you cancel, and have that spelled out in the written agreement. If it is missing, ask for it to be added, and understand any pushback. Some agents charge early-cancellation fees; whether to take on that risk is the seller's call. A one-year listing, or 90 days' notice to cancel, is a red flag. Our agreements are for reasonable amounts of time, and either party can cancel with reasonable written notice.